The weeks after a customer's first order are the best chance you have to earn a second one. The purchase is fresh. They are watching for shipping updates. You have a natural reason to be in touch.
Many stores send a shipping confirmation and then go quiet. By the time the next newsletter arrives, the customer has moved on. This guide gives you a simple 30-day plan that uses your loyalty program to build the habit of coming back.
A note on emails: Gratify sends two emails automatically: one when a customer earns points on an order, and one when their reward code is ready. The other emails in this guide come from your own email tool. Gratify does not sync point balances to other tools, so keep those emails general. Each customer's personal balance lives in the loyalty widget on your store.
Before the first order: get customers logged in
Every loyalty action in Gratify needs a customer account. Points are earned only when the customer is logged in. A guest checkout earns nothing, and those points cannot be added later.
This is the biggest leak in most post-purchase plans, so fix it first.
- Offer sign-up points. Gratify's Account Creation reward gives one-time points. The customer claims them in the loyalty widget once they are logged in.
- Make the widget easy to find. Once the app embed is on, the widget launcher shows on every page of your store. Guests who click earn or redeem are sent to your login page.
- Mention points before checkout. A short line in your cart or announcement bar, such as "Log in to earn points on this order", reminds shoppers while it still counts.
If customers say their points are missing, the guests can't earn points article explains the usual cause.
Day 0: the order is placed
When a logged-in customer completes an order, Gratify awards order points. If you turned on points after fulfilment, the points show as pending and are credited when the order is fulfilled. Otherwise they are credited when the order is paid.
Gratify then emails the customer to say how many points they earned, as long as they have an email address. You do not need to set this up. It is the first moment the customer sees that points are building.
You can also add a line to Shopify's order confirmation template, such as: "You are earning points on this order. Open the rewards panel on our store to see your balance." Keep it general. Shopify templates cannot show a Gratify balance.
Day 1: introduce the program
Send first-time buyers a short welcome from your email tool. Explain the program in plain terms:
- How they earn: points per order, sign-up points, and any other ways to earn you have turned on.
- What they can get: your rewards and what each one costs in points.
- Where to check: the loyalty widget, which shows their balance, any points expiring soon and their VIP tier progress.
Do not try to explain everything on day one. Start with points. Birthdays, social actions and tiers can come later.
Days 5 to 7: the product arrives
This is when the customer forms their opinion of your product. Send a check-in from your email tool. Ask how it is going and offer help if they need it.
You can add a light loyalty prompt here. Invite them to add their birthday in the widget. Gratify's Birthday Reward gives one-time points when a customer adds their birthday. It is paid once, when the date is added. It is not paid on the birthday itself. A Special Date Reward, such as an anniversary you choose, works the same way. See birthday points.
If you ask for reviews, do it through your review app. Points for reviews are coming soon to Gratify, so do not promise review points yet.
Day 14: point to the next reward
Two weeks in, give the customer a concrete goal for order two. Send an email that names your lowest-cost reward. For example: "Our free shipping reward starts at 300 points. Open the rewards panel to see how close you are."
The widget does the personal part. Its Redeem tab lists every reward, and rewards the customer cannot afford yet are disabled. That makes the next goal clear without your email needing their balance.
This step only works if the first reward really is close. If customers earn 1 point per dollar and your cheapest reward costs 2,000 points, the goal is too far away. Set at least one reward within reach of one or two orders. The reward engine overview covers your options.
Day 21: add another way to earn
A happy customer is more willing to engage with your brand. Mention the other ways to earn you have turned on:
- Social Follow Rewards: points for following you on Facebook, X, LinkedIn, Instagram or TikTok, once per platform.
- Social Share Rewards: points for sharing a product link, up to the limit you set.
These actions are honour-based and not verified, so keep the points modest. A referral program is coming soon to Gratify. Until it arrives, do not promise referral points.
Day 30: check in based on what they did
By day 30, split first-time buyers into two groups in Shopify, using their order count.
- Placed a second order: thank them. Remind them that their balance is growing. If you run VIP tiers, explain how they can move up.
- No second order yet: send a friendly reminder that they have points waiting. Invite them back to see your rewards. Do not promise bonus points. Gratify has no manual point adjustments, so you cannot add points to an account by hand.
If you want a time-limited reason to return, a double points event works for everyone. Set it up as a Festival Reward with a start and an end date. It multiplies order points on every order placed in that window. See double points events.
Customers who stay quiet after day 30 are ready for a longer win-back plan, with emails spaced a couple of weeks apart.
What makes this plan work
- Visible progress. Customers see their balance, expiring points and tier progress every time they open the widget. Your emails point them there.
- A near-term goal. The next reward should always feel one or two orders away.
- Gradual depth. Points first, then birthdays and social actions, then tiers. Discovery feels better than a wall of rules.
Measure the result with your repeat purchase rate. Our guide to repeat purchase rate shows how to track it by cohort, so you can see whether this plan lifts second orders.
Give first-time buyers a reason to return
Gratify awards points on every logged-in order, with sign-up and birthday points to start the habit. Free on the Shopify App Store.
Explore the points programReady to turn buyers into repeat customers?
Gratify is free to install. Points, VIP tiers, and referrals - live in five minutes, no credit card required.
Install Gratify Free →⭐ Free on the Shopify App Store · Instant setup · No credit card
