A customer who bought three months ago and has not returned is not lost. They are lapsed. The difference matters. Lost customers need to be found again, often with ad spend. Lapsed customers usually need a relevant reminder.
A loyalty program gives you a reminder that is not a discount: the points they have already earned. This guide shows how to build a win-back sequence around them.
A note on emails: Gratify sends two emails automatically: one when a customer earns points on an order, and one when their reward code is ready. The other emails in this guide come from your own email tool. Gratify does not track lapsed customers or send win-back emails. Smart segments for win-back targeting are coming soon.
Define lapsed for your store
The right window depends on how often people buy from you. A store selling weekly consumables might call a customer lapsed after 30 days. A furniture store might wait 18 months.
A useful rule of thumb: a customer is lapsed when they have gone about twice your normal gap between orders without buying. Work out your typical gap from your Shopify order reports.
Find your lapsed customers
Build the list in Shopify. Shopify customer segments can filter customers by when they last ordered and how many orders they have placed. Use that segment as the audience in your email tool, such as Shopify Email.
Gratify's Customers page is useful for a quick look. It lists each member with their points, VIP tier and last activity, and you can search, filter and sort the table. Gratify has no member export, so build send lists in Shopify. The members list guide explains each column.
The win-back sequence
Space the emails about two weeks apart. Daily emails feel desperate. A slower pace feels considered. The day numbers below assume a 90-day lapse window, so adjust them to yours.
Your email tool cannot see each customer's balance. So write every email to send customers to the loyalty widget. Once they log in, the widget shows their balance, any points expiring soon and the rewards they can claim.
Email 1: points reminder (day 90)
Subject idea: "You have points waiting for you". Keep it simple. Remind them they have been earning points, list your rewards and link to the store. Ask them to log in and open the rewards panel to see their balance.
This is the gentlest email in the sequence. It costs nothing and tests whether a reminder is enough.
Email 2: show what points buy (day 105)
Subject idea: "Here is what your points can get you". List your rewards and their points cost, from cheapest to most valuable. In the widget, rewards the customer cannot afford yet are disabled, so they see at a glance which reward is within reach.
Email 3: expiry reminder (day 120)
Only send this if you use points expiry. Gratify can expire points after a set number of days. The widget shows an "Expiring soon" figure and date, but Gratify does not send expiry emails. Your email can say: "Unused points expire. Check the rewards panel to see whether any of yours are expiring soon."
Real expiry is honest urgency. Do not invent a deadline. See points expiry for how it works.
Email 4: a reason to come back now (day 135)
Many win-back sequences add free bonus points at this stage. Gratify has no manual point adjustments, so you cannot add points to an account. Use a time-limited double points event instead.
Set up a Festival Reward for a short window, such as one week, with a 2x multiplier. It applies to every order in that window, not only lapsed customers, which keeps it simple and fair. Tell lapsed customers about it in this email: "Double points on every order this week." Always set both a start and an end date. See double points events.
Email 5: final check-in (day 150)
Send a short, warm note. Thank them, remind them their account and rewards are still there, and link to the store. If they do not respond, pause win-back emails to them for a few months.
When they come back
The returning customer logs in, opens the widget and redeems. Gratify creates a single-use discount code that is valid for 7 days and emails it to them. They paste it at checkout. Their new order earns fresh points, and if you run VIP tiers, their progress keeps building.
If a customer says their code does not work, see reward code troubleshooting. Common causes include an expired code or an order below the reward's minimum.
Measure your results
Win-back results vary widely by store, product and list quality, so measure your own. Track how many customers in your lapsed segment place an order within 30 days of the first email. Compare that with a period before you started.
Gratify's Activity feed and Analytics show redemptions over time. That tells you whether returning customers are using their points. The dashboard and analytics guide explains what each chart shows.
What not to do
- Do not open with a discount. It tells customers that waiting pays. Start with the points reminder, which costs nothing.
- Do not email daily. Two weeks between emails is plenty.
- Do not promise what the program cannot do. Avoid "we have added points to your account" or a personal balance in the email. Send customers to the widget instead.
- Do not give up too soon. Some customers go quiet for months, then come back for years. Keep your suppression window generous.
Win-back works best alongside a strong start. If many customers lapse after one order, look at what happens in their first 30 days. Repeat purchase rate is the metric that shows whether both are working.
Show customers the points they already have
The Gratify loyalty widget shows each logged-in customer their balance, expiring points and rewards on every page of your store.
Explore the loyalty widgetReady to turn buyers into repeat customers?
Gratify is free to install. Points, VIP tiers, and referrals - live in five minutes, no credit card required.
Install Gratify Free →⭐ Free on the Shopify App Store · Instant setup · No credit card
